Recommend addition/removal of words
-
@sakamvari, @agentcarter, why is this even a topic in the list if words cannot be added or removed??
-
@mapmakere Good point. It's probably not going to change anything (unless the official dictionary people are following this), but it does promote an interesting discussion nonetheless.
-
@roymccoy you would...Shows total lack of consideration, but, .maybe you could ask op if they are offended by your lack of vocabulary and consideration. Happy New Year
-
@dan
Then it is confusing to see the following offer from Lexulous:"Lexulous (2 May 2020)
You may use this topic for recommending words to be added/removed from the Lexulous Word Lists"I would infer that Lexulous creates its own lists of words to use on this site i.e. that it can choose whatever words it wants.
Please Lexulous, can you clarify this point for us!
-
@mistertoad
Or, preferably, correct the cockup. -
@roymccoy most people police their own
-
@b-birney Sorry but, every definition of jew is pejorative. As long as it is not a proper noun, it is intended as an insult
-
@roymccoy said in Recommend addition/removal of words:
Also, not sure if anyone else has noticed but the word 'myspace' (the social media website from 00s) is in the Lexulous dictionary!
How about "ebaying"?
I came across "ebay" as a valid word on Lex UK. That is a new level of ridiculous if you expect a game with defined, adhered to, rules.
-
It appears that this topic is a "hornet's nest". For each person who wants to include a "new" word, someone else wants it excluded and vice versa. There are lots of dictionaries out there, and there are always going to be differences at the margin. I had understood that the way out of this conundrum is to use one standardised dictionary for all games, and I believe that what is known as SOWPODS is the Scrabble standard, although there is a different standard in N. America. Lexulous admin, why don't you cut through this confusion and adopt one or two optional standards (how about SOWPODS and the USA equivalent?) instead of your own version?
-
@jpcoh1 I don't think it's really that difficult. Most people who make valid suggestions for the removal of words usually have a good case put forward for why. The only ones that usually dont make sense are the overly sensitive women that dont like the word 'cunt.' (Or whatever derogatory term they decide to pick on that day.)
Also, I'm pretty sure that Lexulous just synchronises it's dictionary with a third-party dictionary online. I find it very doubtful that they have their own. So to be honest, I'm not sure if it's even possible for them to remove words. They would probably either themselves have to contact the owners of the online dictionary they have synchronised their dictionary with, or synchronise it with a different dictionary. Which would probably explain why it never gets changed, because they simply can't be arsed!
-
@l-j Yeah, Lex appears to use the latest official tournament word lists. That's a good thing.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASPA_Word_List
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collins_Scrabble_WordsThe best course of action for those serious about adding or removing certain words would be to contact Merriam-Webster and/or Collins.
-
@dan Yeah, see, that makes more sense.
-
@lexulous said in Recommend addition/removal of words (2 May 2020):
You may use this topic for recommending words to be added/removed from the Lexulous Word Lists.
I'm growing increasingly annoyed at the endless continuation of this discussion, based on the initial stated premise, by lexulous, that Lexulous word lists exist that are open to modification and thus presumably have been and can continue to be edited.
Is this the case or not? I believe we've established that it isn't, and yet there continue to be messages such as @jpcoh1's yesterday expressing the belief that words can actually be added or removed from the Lexulous lists. The situation could be corrected if it were only acknowledged and addressed. I suppose various solutions are possible, but one might be that @lexulous edit the original message to correct the misimpression, that this thread possibly be closed for further comments (if that's possible), and that a new thread or section be initiated with a less misleading name – "Discussion about words", for example, or anything avoiding the erroneous implication that exceptional changes to the Lexulous dictionaries can or will appear.
-
@dan
OK, thank you for this but I do think that Lexulous should clarify the issue officially on the site.Lexulous, please may we have a clear statement with regard to your word list somewhere on the site ?
-
A Former Userreplied to roymccoy on 3 Jan 2022, 20:17 last edited by A Former User 1 Mar 2022, 20:56
@roymccoy Isn't this the thread/topic that started life as 'Please remove the word jew'? At some point I think the title was changed and general theme expanded, either by the admins (most likely) or by the original poster.
-
@dan said in Recommend addition/removal of words:
@roymccoy Isn't this the thread/topic that started life as 'Please remove the word jew'? At some point I think the title was changed and general theme was expanded, either by the admins (most likely) or by the original poster.
I don't know, but it doesn't matter in regard to what Mistertoad and I are saying.
181/259